Absolutely Amazing Product and Customer Service out of 5 stars
I don’t usually write reviews, but my first pair of Todd Shelton Classic 12 jeans absolutely deserve one. I wanted to wear the jeans a few times, too, before writing my review. I apologize for the length of the review, but I hope it helps someone.
As a shorter guy, finding jeans that actually fit properly—without needing expensive tailoring—has always been a struggle. These are hands-down the best pair I’ve ever ordered.
Fit:
The fit is phenomenal. The proportions are clearly designed for shorter frames, not just “regular jeans made shorter.” The rise sits perfectly, the knee break hits where it should, and the taper is clean without being too skinny. No bunching at the ankles, no awkward stacking, no baggy thighs. I put them on and for the first time thought, these were actually made for me.
Material:
The 100% cotton denim feels premium right out of the box. Soft with just the right amount of stretch—comfortable enough for all-day wear but structured enough to hold its shape. They don’t sag after a few hours, and they move with you instead of feeling stiff. You can tell this isn’t cheap denim; it feels durable and well-constructed.
Customer Service:
Beyond the jeans, the customer service that Todd extended was outstanding. I had a quick sizing question before ordering and got a fast, thoughtful reply that helped me choose the perfect size. Then I was shipped a try-on pair just to make sure with free return shipping. I let Todd know that the sizing was awesome, sent back the try-on pair, and then waited for my jeans to be made. Shipping was smooth, and everything arrived exactly as promised. It’s rare to feel genuinely taken care of as a customer, but Todd and his crew nailed it.
Overall, these jeans completely exceeded my expectations. If you’re a shorter guy tired of compromising on fit, these are 100% worth it. I’ll definitely be ordering another pair.
Response from Todd Shelton
February 27, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to write such a thoughtful review. When we started the factory, we realized we could solve fit problems guys had faced all their lives (mine included). Your comments are a reminder of the importance of in-house manufacturing.
Perfect fit out of 5 stars
For about the same price as a good quality shirt off the rack Todd Shelton allows you to customize for a perfect fit. The quality of fabrics they use are top notch and the sewing is perfect. Great American made clothing!
The best in the US out of 5 stars
Been using Todd Shelton for semi-custom shirts for a few years now. Fantastic quality top to bottom, good service that will help you tweak your fit, great cloths, good quality construction. I get compliments on my TS shirts almost every time I wear one. Made in the USA -- that means something.
Thank you for what you do and who you are out of 5 stars
Being from a working-class background, and the first in my family to go to college, it means a great deal to me that you provide jobs which give people dignity in their lives. Everyone should make a living wage, and be proud of what they do and the skills they have. Your model of doing business honors that. So, I buy your clothes. As a teacher, I tell my students about the difference between letting folks make the whole piece rather than just doing the same repetitive task all day. What that does to the body, sure, but ultimately what that does to a person's self-worth and feeling of accomplishment.
I am proud to wear the quality that Todd Shelton stands for, the timeless (and unflashy) design, but more importantly the labor and environmental standards woven into it all.
American made! out of 5 stars
Both my shirts are awesome, I could not be happier! I try to purchase only American made clothing, and you have made the process of buying custom made shirts effortless. Jessica followed up on my first order and she was professional, upbeat and a credit to your company! I will now be a long term customer of your company.
Perfect out of 5 stars
I just received my latest order, and everything came out perfect. I wore the last shirts right up until the elbows gave out and the wrists were completely frayed, so this refresh feels great.
I am a convert out of 5 stars
I was thinking of my jeans moments ago. True story. I am a convert.
Thanks for starting your company out of 5 stars
I wanted to say thanks for starting your company. I love the company's mission and products!
Out of This World out of 5 stars
Your incredible attention to detail and high quality are just out of this world. I’m constantly banging the Todd Shelton drum to anyone who will listen.
Exceptional out of 5 stars
Not one to leave reviews, but I tell everyone I know who likes quality clothing about Todd Shelton. When I'm asked "where are those jeans from?" I can't help saying "these are the only jeans I wear." Because I wear denim every single day.
My collection of Todd Shelton jeans has been years in the making, not a big splurge. And that just goes to show how well they hold up to the promise of quality. Not to mention, having a personal concierge like Jessica is invaluable when making an investment in high quality garments.
My favorite fit = The Classic 12. I once wore a single pair of the FKA San Francisco's almost every day for a year. They still look amazing, and fit better than ever.
Response from Todd Shelton
October 27, 2025
Thanks so much for the kind words and for spreading the word about TS! We're glad to hear you're loving all your jeans and that they've become an everyday staple. Like you, we believe jeans are the foundation of every great outfit. Great minds think alike!
Perfect Fit, Exceptional Service out of 5 stars
I recently purchased The Parisian shirt from Todd Shelton, and it exceeded my expectations in every way. The craftsmanship and fabric quality are outstanding, but what truly sets the experience apart is the custom fit. Jessica, my Fit Planner, was fantastic—knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely focused on helping me get the perfect fit. Her friendly expertise made the entire process easy and enjoyable. I couldn’t be happier with the result—this shirt feels like it was made just for me. Highly recommend both The Parisian and the Todd Shelton team.
Response from Todd Shelton
October 21, 2025
We're so glad to know that you're loving the fit of your new Parisian Poplin shirt. Thanks so much for the great review and compliment. We really appreciate it!
Great quality jeans! Terrific customer service! out of 5 stars
I picked up two pairs of 13 oz sturdy selvedge denim jeans—one in a dark wash and one in a light wash. The fit was already great, but I had them tapered by my local tailor and now they’re perfect. They feel built to last for years and look great—which score these jeans major points. Big thanks to Jessica from Todd Shelton’s support team—she’s been terrific in answering my questions. Definitely recommend the jeans, I've been looking for a great brand for jeans as I've had sub-par ones prior. Todd Shelton is the quality I've been looking for.
Denim 12 oz out of 5 stars
Very good quality and the fit is just right. I will be ordering another pair in the near future and I highly recommend them!
Response from Todd Shelton
October 01, 2025
We're so happy to hear you're loving your Classic 12 lightwash jeans, and we really appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback!
Great Fit out of 5 stars
My Todd Shelton jeans fit me better than other brands; my combination of waist and inseam is not common. I especially appreciate the double belt loop at the back of the pants. That prevents your leather belt from developing a permanent curl. Very well constructed. I have even received compliments on them and that is unusual for jeans.
Response from Todd Shelton
June 25, 2025
That's great to hear! We're glad the jeans are a good fit and that you appreciate the design details, especially the double belt loops!
High quality out of 5 stars
Amazing quality jeans/shirts and the way you can dial in the fit is genius and extremely well thought out. Will not buy jeans from anywhere else again. Great customer service as well.
Response from Todd Shelton
June 25, 2025
We're so glad to hear you're enjoying the fit and quality of your jeans and shirts, and that our customer service met your expectations. We really appreciate your loyalty!
Excellent service and quality shirt out of 5 stars
I went through multiple iterations of fit with the Oxford shirt, helped by Jessica, and was amazed at the level of service and that I was worked with to get the right fit. It is very comfortable fabric, and a shirt I look forward to wearing for a long time.
Response from Todd Shelton
June 12, 2025
Glad to hear you had such a positive experience with Jessica and found your perfect Oxford shirt. We appreciate your review!"
Best Ever out of 5 stars
The original 13 mid-wash jeans are uncompromisingly the best I’ve found. The fabric has a lovely hand, something only rarely heard in the world of denim. Fit was exactly as I ordered with a perfect rise allowing belting at my waist & still having a usable fly. Not without a fiscal hit, but well worth it in the long run of comfort & durability. Thank you Todd Shelton
Response from Todd Shelton
May 27, 2025
We really appreciate you sharing your detailed feedback on the Original 13 mid-wash jeans. We are happy to know they meet your expectations for fabric quality, fit.
Classic 12 Light out of 5 stars
Perfect fit and arrived early! Easy to dress up or down with this pair of jeans.
Response from Todd Shelton
May 12, 2025
That's awesome. We're so glad you like the jeans and appreciate their versatility. Thanks for the great review.
Love my stone Badland's pants out of 5 stars
I wore the Badlands for the first time today... they're so soft you don't even need underwear. :)
Response from Todd Shelton
March 24, 2025
Wow, that sounds soft. Thanks for the fun review!
Perfect fit and outstanding quality out of 5 stars
Absolutely love the Rustic tan jeans. Perfect color and fit. I am always delighted to be rewarded with quality, which is why I go for it. Keep going, you guys!
Response from Todd Shelton
March 07, 2025
Thanks so much for sharing! We're so glad you love your Rustics.
Raw denim out of 5 stars
New raw denim jeans feel great. I am waiting for compliments! Never too old for blue jeans. The fit is great.
Response from Todd Shelton
February 26, 2025
We're so glad you're loving your new raw jeans. The compliments are sure to come! Thanks so much for your support.
Favorite T-shirts out of 5 stars
These are the best t-shirts for me because they are customizable. I'm tall with a long upper body, so being able to add 2 inches of length gives me a t-shirt that's not awkwardly short. The quality is also fanastic, my favorite are the slub fabric. Customer service is also first class. Great company and great products.
Response from Todd Shelton
February 25, 2025
Thanks so much for your sentiments. A t-shirt that's too short is a deal breaker for sure. Glad we could help!
Level Up out of 5 stars
I recently ordered Todd Shelton's slub t-shirts, and I couldn't be more satisfied with the purchase. I got both black and white options in crew neck, including both short-sleeve and long-sleeve.
The slub material is exceptional—smooth to the touch yet textured enough to add character without being overly rugged. What impressed me was how well the fabric drapes against my body. It's rare to find t-shirts that achieve that perfect balance of structure and softness, but they nailed it. The shirts maintain their shape beautifully, even after numerous washes, without any signs of stretching, shrinking, or fading. That durability speaks volumes about the quality of the material and the care put into discovering this material.
One of my favorite aspects of the Todd Shelton experience was the attention to detail, especially regarding fit. Their customer service team was super helpful in guiding me through the customization options, ensuring I found the perfect fit for my body type. They prioritize delivering an experience that was tailored my body.
These slub t-shirts have quickly become my go-to choice for everyday wear. Whether I’m dressing casually with jeans or layering them under a jacket, they offer versatility while maintaining a clean, polished look.
My ask is that Todd provides more color options for the slub. I'll probably get them all.
Response from Todd Shelton
February 26, 2025
Thank you for the thoughtful review. We're so glad you love your t-shirts and find them comfortable and versatile. Your request for more colors is noted. We're always on the lookout!
Quality Dress Shirts out of 5 stars
Todd Shelton has been my source for quality dress shirts for over 12 years.
Response from Todd Shelton
February 19, 2025
That's wonderful to hear! We're honored to have been your choice for quality dress shirts for over 12 years. Thank you for your continued loyalty.
Great Company out of 5 stars
About 5 years ago I looked in my closet and recognized how much money I was wasting on cheap clothing I hardly wore. Came across Todd Shelton, was impressed with the Customer Service and quality of the first pair of khakis I purchased (and still wear) and over time have added oxfords, t shirts, sweatshirts, jeans, shorts. Everything fits, pairs well and lasts making life simpler. Best of all I am supporting a US manufacturer which treats its employees well.
Response from Todd Shelton
February 13, 2025
Thank you for sharing. We're glad to know you've found value in our quality and fit. We appreciate your support of our US manufacturing and commitment to treating our employees well. We look forward to continuing to provide you with lasting, versatile clothing.
